Wed, 17 Nov 2021 11:19
  
                  
                      Revealed: Documents show Bill G8S has 'given' $319 Million to Media Outlets  By:  Alan MacLeod, PhD
  
                      Seattle (November 16, 2021):   Up until his recent messy divorce,   Bill Gates   enjoyed something of a free pass in corporate media. Generally presented as a kindly nerd who wants to save the world, the   Microsoft   co-founder was even unironically christened   ''Saint Bill''   by   The Guardian  .
  
                      While other billionaires' media empires are relatively well known, the extent to which Gates's cash underwrites the modern media landscape is not. After sorting through over 30,000 individual grants, MintPress can reveal that the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF) has made over $300 million worth of donations to fund media projects.
  
                      Recipients of this cash include many of America's most important news outlets, including CNN, NBC, NPR, PBS and The Atlantic. Gates also sponsors a myriad of influential foreign organizations, including the BBC, The Guardian, The Financial Times and The Daily Telegraph in the United Kingdom; prominent European newspapers such as Le Monde (France), Der Spiegel (Germany) and El Pas (Spain); as well as big global broadcasters like Al-Jazeera.
  
                      The Gates Foundation money going towards media programs has been split up into a number of sections, presented in descending numerical order, and includes a link to the relevant grant on the organization's website.
  
                      Awards Directly to Media Outlets:
  
                      NPR- $24,663,066
  
                      The Guardian (including TheGuardian.org)- $12,951,391
  
                      Cascade Public Media '' $10,895,016
  
                      Public Radio International (PRI.org/TheWorld.org)- $7,719,113
  
                      The Conversation- $6,664,271
  
                      Univision- $5,924,043
  
                      Der Spiegel (Germany)- $5,437,294
  
                      Project Syndicate- $5,280,186
  
                      Education Week '' $4,898,240
  
                      WETA- $4,529,400
  
                      NBCUniversal Media- $4,373,500
  
                      Nation Media Group (Kenya) '' $4,073,194
  
                      Le Monde (France)- $4,014,512
  
                      Bhekisisa (South Africa) '' $3,990,182
  
                      El Pas '' $3,968,184
  
                      BBC- $3,668,657
  
                      CNN- $3,600,000
  
                      KCET- $3,520,703
  
                      Population Communications International (population.org) '' $3,500,000
  
                      The Daily Telegraph '' $3,446,801
  
                      Chalkbeat '' $2,672,491
  
                      The Education Post- $2,639,193
  
                      Rockhopper Productions (U.K.) '' $2,480,392
  
                      Corporation for Public Broadcasting '' $2,430,949
  
                      UpWorthy '' $2,339,023
  
                      Financial Times '' $2,309,845
  
                      The 74 Media- $2,275,344
  
                      Texas Tribune- $2,317,163
  
                      Punch (Nigeria) '' $2,175,675
  
                      News Deeply '' $1,612,122
  
                      The Atlantic- $1,403,453
  
                      Minnesota Public Radio- $1,290,898
  
                      YR Media- $1,125,000
  
                      The New Humanitarian- $1,046,457
  
                      Sheger FM (Ethiopia) '' $1,004,600
  
                      Al-Jazeera- $1,000,000
  
                      ProPublica- $1,000,000
  
                      Crosscut Public Media '' $810,000
  
                      Grist Magazine- $750,000
  
                      Kurzgesagt '' $570,000
  
                      Educational Broadcasting Corp '' $506,504
  
                      Classical 98.1 '' $500,000
  
                      PBS '' $499,997
  
                      Gannett '' $499,651
  
                      Mail and Guardian (South Africa)- $492,974
  
                      Inside Higher Ed.- $439,910
  
                      BusinessDay (Nigeria) '' $416,900
  
                      Medium.com '' $412,000
  
                      Nutopia- $350,000
  
                      Independent Television Broadcasting Inc. '' $300,000
  
                      Independent Television Service, Inc. '' $300,000
  
                      Caixin Media (China) '' $250,000
  
                      Pacific News Service '' $225,000
  
                      National Journal '' $220,638
  
                      Chronicle of Higher Education '' $149,994
  
                      Belle and Wissell, Co. $100,000
  
                      Media Trust '' $100,000
  
                      New York Public Radio '' $77,290
  
                      KUOW '' Puget Sound Public Radio '' $5,310
  
                      Together, these donations total $166,216,526. The money is generally directed towards issues close to the Gateses hearts. For example, the $3.6 million CNN grant went towards ''report[ing] on gender equality with a particular focus on least developed countries, producing journalism on the everyday inequalities endured by women and girls across the world,'' while the Texas Tribune received millions to ''to increase public awareness and engagement of education reform issues in Texas.'' Given that Bill is one of the charter schools' most   fervent supporters  , a cynic might interpret this as planting pro-corporate charter school propaganda into the media, disguised as objective news reporting.
  
                      The Gates Foundation has also given nearly $63 million to charities closely aligned with big media outlets, including nearly   $53 million   to BBC Media Action, over   $9 million   to MTV's Staying Alive Foundation, and   $1 million   to The New York Times Neediest Causes Fund. While not specifically funding journalism, donations to the philanthropic arm of a media player should still be noted.
  
                      Gates continues to underwrite a wide network of investigative journalism centers as well, totaling just over $38 million, more than half of which has gone to the D.C.-based International Center for Journalists to expand and develop African media.
  
                      These centers include:
  
                      International Center for Journalists- $20,436,938
  
                      Premium Times Centre for Investigative Journalism (Nigeria) '' $3,800,357
  
                      The Pulitzer Center for Crisis Reporting '' $2,432,552
  
                      Fondation EurActiv Politech '' $2,368,300
  
                      International Women's Media Foundation '' $1,500,000
  
                      Center for Investigative Reporting '' $1,446,639
  
                      InterMedia Survey institute '' $1,297,545
  
                      The Bureau of Investigative Journalism '' $1,068,169
  
                      Internews Network '' $985,126
  
                      Communications Consortium Media Center '' $858,000
  
                      Institute for Nonprofit News '' $650,021
  
                      The Poynter Institute for Media Studies- $382,997
  
                      Wole Soyinka Centre for Investigative Journalism (Nigeria) '' $360,211
  
                      Institute for Advanced Journalism Studies '' $254,500
  
                      Global Forum for Media Development (Belgium) '' $124,823
  
                      Mississippi Center for Investigative Reporting '' $100,000
  
                      In addition to this, the Gates Foundation also plies press and journalism associations with cash, to the tune of at least $12 million. For example, the National Newspaper Publishers Association '-- a group representing more than 200 outlets '-- has received $3.2 million.
  
                      The list of these organizations includes:
  
                      Education Writers Association '' $5,938,475
  
                      National Newspaper Publishers Association '' $3,249,176
  
                      National Press Foundation- $1,916,172
  
                      Washington News Council- $698,200
  
                      American Society of News Editors Foundation '' $250,000
  
                      Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press- $25,000
  
                      This brings our running total up to $216.4 million.
  
                      The foundation also puts up the money to directly train journalists all over the world, in the form of scholarships, courses and workshops. Today, it is possible for an individual to train as a reporter thanks to a Gates Foundation grant, find work at a Gates-funded outlet, and to belong to a press association funded by Gates. This is especially true of journalists working in the fields of health, education and global development, the ones Gates himself is most active in and where scrutiny of the billionaire's actions and motives are most necessary.
  
                      Gates Foundation grants pertaining to the instruction of journalists include:
  
                      Johns Hopkins University '' $1,866,408
  
                      Teachers College, Columbia University- $1,462,500
  
                      University of California Berkeley- $767,800
  
                      Tsinghua University (China) '' $450,000
  
                      Seattle University '' $414,524
  
                      Institute for Advanced Journalism Studies '' $254,500
  
                      Rhodes University (South Africa) '' $189,000
  
                      Montclair State University- $160,538
  
                      Pan-Atlantic University Foundation '' $130,718
  
                      World Health Organization '' $38,403
  
                      The Aftermath Project- $15,435
  
                      The BMGF also pays for a wide range of specific media campaigns around the world. For example, since 2014 it has donated $5.7 million to the Population Foundation of India in order to create dramas that promote sexual and reproductive health, with the intent to increase family planning methods in South Asia. Meanwhile, it allotted over   $3.5 million   to a Senegalese organization to develop radio shows and online content that would feature health information. Supporters consider this to be helping critically underfunded media, while opponents might consider it a case of a billionaire using his money to plant his ideas and opinions into the press.
  
                      Media projects supported by the Gates Foundation:
  
                      European Journalism Centre '' $20,060,048
  
                      World University Service of Canada '' $12,127,622
  
                      Well Told Story Limited '' $9,870,333
  
                      Solutions Journalism Inc.- $7,254,755
  
                      Entertainment Industry Foundation '' $6,688,208
  
                      Population Foundation of India- $5,749,826 ''
  
                      Participant Media '' $3,914,207
  
                      R(C)seau Africain de l'Education pour la sant(C)- $3,561,683
  
                      New America '' $3,405,859
  
                      AllAfrica Foundation '' $2,311,529
  
                      Steps International '' $2,208,265
  
                      Center for Advocacy and Research '' $2,200,630
  
                      The Sesame Workshop '' $2,030,307
  
                      Panos Institute West Africa '' $1,809,850
  
                      Open Cities Lab '' $1,601,452
  
                      Harvard university '' $1,190,527
  
                      Learning Matters '' $1,078,048
  
                      The Aaron Diamond Aids Research Center- $981,631
  
                      Thomson Media Foundation- $860,628
  
                      Communications Consortium Media Center '' $858,000
  
                      StoryThings- $799,536
  
                      Center for Rural Strategies '' $749,945
  
                      The New Venture Fund '' $700,000
  
                      Helianthus Media '' $575,064
  
                      University of Southern California- $550,000
  
                      World Health Organization- $530,095
  
                      Phi Delta Kappa International '' $446,000
  
                      Ikana Media '' $425,000
  
                      Seattle Foundation '' $305,000
  
                      EducationNC '' $300,000
  
                      Beijing Guokr Interactive '' $300,000
  
                      Upswell- $246,918
  
                      The African Academy of Sciences '' $208,708
  
                      Seeking Modern Applications for Real Transformation (SMART) '' $201,781
  
                      Bay Area Video Coalition- $190,000
  
                      PowHERful Foundation '' $185,953
  
                      PTA Florida Congress of Parents and Teachers '' $150,000
  
                      ProSocial '' $100,000
  
                      Boston University '' $100,000
  
                      National Center for Families Learning '' $100,000
  
                      Development Media International '' $100,000
  
                      Ahmadu Bello University- $100,000
  
                      Indonesian eHealth and Telemedicine Society '' $100,000
  
                      The Filmmakers Collaborative '' $50,000
  
                      Foundation for Public Broadcasting in Georgia Inc. '' $25,000
  
                      SIFF '' $13,000
  
                      Total: $97,315,408
  
                      $319.4 MILLION AND (A LOT) MORE    Added together, these Gates-sponsored media projects come to a total of $319.4 million. However, there are clear shortcomings with this non-exhaustive list, meaning the true figure is undoubtedly far higher. First, it does not count sub-grants '-- money given by recipients to media around the world. And while the Gates Foundation fosters an air of openness about itself, there is actually precious little public information about what happens to the money from each grant, save for a short, one- or two-sentence description written by the foundation itself on its website. Only donations to press organizations themselves or projects that could be identified from the information on the Gates Foundation's website as media campaigns were counted, meaning that thousands of grants having some media element do not appear in this list.
  
                      A case in point is the BMGF's partnership with ViacomCBS, the company that controls CBS News, MTV, VH1, Nickelodeon, and BET. Media reports at the time   noted   that the Gates Foundation was paying the entertainment giant to insert information and PSAs into its programming and that Gates had intervened to change storylines in popular shows like ER and Law & Order: SVU.
  
                      However, when checking BMGF's grants database, ''Viacom'' and ''CBS'' are nowhere to be found, the likely   grant   in question (totaling over $6 million) merely describing the project as a ''public engagement campaign aimed at improving high school graduation rates and postsecondary completion rates specifically aimed at parents and students,'' meaning that it was not counted in the official total. There are surely many more examples like this. ''For a tax-privileged charity that so very often trumpets the importance of transparency, it's remarkable how intensely secretive the Gates Foundation is about its financial flows,''   Tim Schwab  , one of the few investigative journalists who has scrutinized the tech billionaire, told MintPress.
  
                      Also not included are grants aimed at producing articles for academic journals. While these articles are not meant for mass consumption, they regularly form the basis for stories in the mainstream press and help shape narratives around key issues. The Gates Foundation has given far and wide to academic sources, with at least   $13.6 million   going toward creating content for the prestigious medical journal The Lancet.
  
                      And, of course, even money given to universities for purely research projects eventually ends up in academic journals, and ultimately, downstream into mass media. Academics are under heavy pressure to print their results in prestigious journals; ''publish or perish'' is the mantra in university departments. Therefore, even these sorts of grants have an effect on our media. Neither these nor grants funding the printing of books or establishment of websites counted in the total, although they too are forms of media.
  
                      LOW PROFILE, LONG TENTACLES    In comparison to other tech billionaires, Gates has kept his profile as a media controller relatively low. Amazon founder   Jeff Bezos's   purchase of The Washington Post for $250 million in 2013 was a very clear and obvious form of media influence, as was eBay founder Pierre Omidyar's creation of First Look Media, the company that owns The Intercept.
  
                      Despite flying more under the radar, Gates and his companies have amassed considerable influence in media. We already rely on Microsoft-owned products for communication (e.g. Skype, Hotmail), social media (LinkedIn), and entertainment (Microsoft XBox). Furthermore, the hardware and software we use to communicate often comes courtesy of the 66-year-old Seattleite. How many people reading this are doing so on a Microsoft Surface or Windows phone and doing so via Windows OS? Not only that, Microsoft owns stakes in media giants such as   Comcast   and   AT&T  . And the ''MS'' in MSNBC stands for Microsoft.
  
                      The Faux Generosity of the Super-Wealthy: Why Bill Gates is a Menace to Society    MEDIA GATES KEEPERS    That the Gates Foundation is underwriting a significant chunk of our media ecosystem leads to serious problems with objectivity. ''The foundation's grants to media organizations'...raise obvious conflict-of-interest questions: How can reporting be unbiased when a major player holds the purse strings?''   wrote   Gates's local Seattle Times in 2011. This was before the newspaper   accepted   BMGF money to fund its ''education lab'' section.
  
                      Schwab's   research   has found that this conflict of interests goes right to the very top: two New York Times columnists had been writing glowingly about the Gates Foundation for years without disclosing that they also work for a group '-- the Solutions Journalism Network '-- that, as shown above, has received over $7 million from the tech billionaire's charity.
  
                      Earlier this year, Schwab also declined to co-report on a story about COVAX for The Bureau of Investigative Journalism, suspecting that the money Gates had been pumping into the outlet would make it impossible to accurately report on a subject so close to Gates's heart. Sure enough, when the article was   published   last month, it repeated the assertion that Gates had little to do with COVAX's failure, mirroring the BMGF's stance and quoting them throughout. Only at the very end of the more than 5,000-word story did it reveal that the organization it was defending was paying the wages of its staff.
  
                      ''I don't believe Gates told The Bureau of Investigative Journalism what to write. I think the bureau implicitly, if subconsciously, knew they had to find a way to tell this story that didn't target their funder. The biasing effects of financial conflicts are complex but very real and reliable,'' Schwab said, describing it as ''a case study in the perils of Gates-funded journalism.''
  
                      MintPress   also contacted the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation for comment, but it did not respond.
  
                      Gates, who amassed his fortune by building a monopoly and zealously guarding his intellectual property, bears significant blame for the failure of the coronavirus vaccine rollout across the world. Quite aside from the COVAX fiasco, he   pressured   Oxford University not to make its publicly-funded vaccine open-source and available to all for free, but instead to partner with private corporation AstraZeneca, a decision that meant that those who could not pay were blocked from using it. That Gates has made over 100   donations   to the university, totaling hundreds of millions of dollars, likely played some role in the decision. To this day, fewer than   5%   of people in low-income countries have received even one dose of COVID vaccine. The death toll from this is immense.
  
                      Poor Nations Left Reeling After Bill Gates Advised Oxford to Ditch Open Source COVID Vaccine    Unfortunately, many of these real criticisms of Gates and his network are obscured by wild and untrue conspiracy theories about such things as inserting microchips in vaccines to control the population. This has meant that genuine critiques of the Microsoft co-founder are often demonetized and algorithmically suppressed, meaning that outlets are strongly dissuaded from covering the topic, knowing they will likely lose money if they do so. The paucity of scrutiny of the world's second-richest individual, in turn, feeds into outlandish suspicions.
  
                      Gates certainly deserves it. Quite apart from his deep and potentially decades-long ties to the infamous Jeffrey Epstein, his   attempts   to   radically   change African society, and his   investment   in controversial chemical giant Monsanto, he is perhaps the key driver behind the American charter school movement '-- an attempt to essentially privatize the U.S. education system. Charter schools are deeply unpopular with teachers' unions, which see the movement as an attempt to lessen their autonomy and reduce public oversight into how and what children are taught.
  
                      ALL THE WAY TO THE BANK    In most coverage, Gates's donations are broadly presented as altruistic gestures. Yet many have pointed to the inherent flaws with this model, noting that allowing billionaires to decide what they do with their money allows them to set the public agenda, giving them enormous power over society. ''Philanthropy can and is being used deliberately to divert attention away from different forms of economic exploitation that underpin global inequality today,''   said     Linsey McGoey  , Professor of Sociology at the University of Essex, U.K., and   author   of No Such Thing as a Free Gift: The Gates Foundation and the Price of Philanthropy. She adds:
  
                      The new 'philanthrocapitalism' threatens democracy by increasing the power of the corporate sector at the expense of the public sector organizations, which increasingly face budget squeezes, in part by excessively remunerating for-profit organizations to deliver public services that could be delivered more cheaply without private sector involvement.''    Charity, as former British Prime Minister Clement Attlee noted, ''is a cold grey loveless thing. If a rich man wants to help the poor, he should pay his taxes gladly, not dole out money at a whim.''
  
                      None of this means that the organizations receiving Gates' money '-- media or otherwise '-- are irredeemably corrupt, nor that the Gates Foundation does not do any good in the world. But it does introduce a glaring conflict of interest whereby the very institutions we rely on to hold accountable one of the richest and most powerful men in the planet's history are quietly being funded by him. This conflict of interest is one that corporate media have largely tried to ignore, while the supposedly altruistic philanthropist Gates just keeps getting richer, laughing all the way to the bank.
  
                      By:   Alan MacLeod   (PhD) is Senior Staff Writer for MintPress News