Steve leads with the Sunday shows: Jonathan Karl's open ('negative stories are called politics'), FIRE's Conor Fitzpatrick (Sherrill v Knight 1977, 'the government isn't supposed to like the press', 'Pandora's box of censorship'), Scalise ('Biden removed 400 credentials' — Karl: not true), Mike Waltz ('within his rights, Zemel v Rusk'; 'garbage gossip journalism… sticks like napalm'), Dana Bash on Madison, Mason and the Sedition Act, Booker ('it clearly violates the Constitution') and Barrasso ('he was banned from Twitter and Facebook, it goes both ways'). Then ours — the press ban in four movements. Friday in the Oval Office: 'every president takes an oath, much more so than you… CNN is fake, MSNOW is MSDNC, Politico got 8 million'; 'why now? no reason, cumulative stories, you get sick of it'. Saturday morning at the gate (ABC7: passes confiscated; MS NOW's Akayla Gardner: the reader blinked red, 'above the officer's head'; no press secretary, they want somebody loyal, watch the pool Monday). The lawyers: viewpoint discrimination and the 1977 DC Circuit case ('such a slam dunk there is no Supreme Court precedent'), Melissa Murray on Zenger 1735 ('a free press is why there was a revolution'), the ABC settlement, CBS: 'every time he explains it it's worse for his legal case'. Then why now: Peter Alexander ('fake news is facts he doesn't like; diesel at 6.48; grenades to distract'; 'he can ban reporters from entering, not from reporting'), 'this is not North Korea', and CNN on the Obama precedent — 'the Obama White House tried to exclude Fox… will Fox repeat that same affirmation?' — answered by the 2009 CBS package as we played it on NA-907 (Feb 2017): Anita Dunn's 'communications arm of the Republican Party', Treasury tries to exclude Fox from the pool, 'all the networks said, that's it, you've crossed the line'; 'not a real news organization', Tapper objects, Fox 'crying all the way to the bank'. Politico's statements (Greenberger, Haslett) are in the article node.
📰 Articles & links (read/context — above the clips)
Clips — 40
00 steve - the sunday shows on the ban
01 S-01- Karl - Trump Banned Three News Organizations, Negative Stories Are Called Politics
📺 Karl — ABC THIS WEEK (?)
Karl (ABC THIS WEEK): "At the end of this week of losses and setbacks, Trump made an extraordinary move. He banned three major news organizations from the White House. Over the weekend, journalists from CNN, MSNOW and Politico had their press passes revoked, their access to the White House denied. Trump was perfectly clear why he did it.
02 S-02- FIRE's Fitzpatrick - Clear For 50 Years, Sherrill v Knight 1977, The AP Case
📺 FIRE's Fitzpatrick — ABC THIS WEEK (?)
FIRE's Fitzpatrick (ABC THIS WEEK): "I'm joined now by Conor Fitzpatrick, an attorney for FIRE, the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, an organization that has consistently defended attacks on free speech from both the left and the right. Conor, thank you for being here.
03 S-03- FIRE's Fitzpatrick - King George, The Government Isn't Supposed To Like The Press
📺 FIRE's Fitzpatrick — ABC THIS WEEK (?)
FIRE's Fitzpatrick (ABC THIS WEEK): "And why should Americans care whether or not reporters are allowed to go and do their job in that building? A free press that feels free to criticize our leaders is core to who we are as a country.
04 S-04- FIRE's Fitzpatrick - The Chilling Effect, Imagine A Democrat Kicking Out Fox
📺 FIRE's Fitzpatrick — ABC THIS WEEK (?)
FIRE's Fitzpatrick (ABC THIS WEEK): "There was something else that Trump said. He said it a couple different ways, suggesting, first of all, there may be other news organizations that will be added to this ban. And that he might bring back those who he has banned if they basically change their, you know, do the right thing.
05 S-05- Scalise - No President More Open, Biden Removed 400 Credentials, Karl - Not True
📺 Scalise — ABC THIS WEEK (?)
Scalise (ABC THIS WEEK): "Welcome back. I'm joined now by one of the top Republicans in Congress, House Majority Leader Steve Scalise. Leader Scalise, let me start with what Trump has now done with the press at the White House.
06 S-06- Scalise - I Don't Know Why He Did It, Karl - Not From Those Three
📺 Scalise — ABC THIS WEEK (?)
Scalise (ABC THIS WEEK): "And what we're seeing now is Trump is saying he is now banning CNN, MSN, MSNOW, and Politico from the White House. Do you support him doing that? Do you think it violates the First Amendment? Well, I don't know why he did it. I don't know what the background is. Look.
07 S-16- Waltz - Within His Rights, Zemel v Rusk, No Right To A Government Facility
📺 Waltz — CNN STATE OF THE UNION (?)
Waltz (CNN STATE OF THE UNION): "On Friday, President Trump banned CNN, MSNOW, and Politico from the White House. The president, as I mentioned, is about to host the Chinese leader. Historically, it was the United States pushing countries like China for greater press freedoms. Now President Trump is the one backsliding on these rights.
08 S-17- Waltz - A Green Beret On The Press Ban, It Sticks To People Like Napalm
📺 Waltz — CNN STATE OF THE UNION (?)
Waltz (CNN STATE OF THE UNION): "Mr. Ambassador, you are a decorated veteran. You served in an elite unit, the Green Berets, for 27 years defending freedoms like the First Amendment. And the president you work for just banned three news organizations, and he said it's because he doesn't like some of the things that are being reported.
09 S-18- Waltz - Negative Reporting Vs Garbage Gossip Journalism
📺 Waltz — CNN STATE OF THE UNION (?)
Waltz (CNN STATE OF THE UNION): "Yeah, well, I mean, there are laws, and we are going to see what the courts say. And then there are norms, and then there is, again, what you have fought for. And we thank you for that service, for these freedoms. And I...
10 S-19- Bash - Madison, Mason, Adams And The Sedition Act
📺 Bash — CNN STATE OF THE UNION (?)
Bash (CNN STATE OF THE UNION): "The difference between having a free press and not is the difference between having a democracy and not. It is just that stark. Don't take my word for it. Take the word of the men who founded this great country.
11 S-20- Booker - It Clearly Violates The Constitution, His DOJ Persecutes Reporters
📺 Booker — NBC MEET THE PRESS (?)
Booker (NBC MEET THE PRESS): "I want to start our conversation where I left off with Senator Barrasso. Get your reaction to this ban by the Trump administration of three major news outlets. Do you think it violates the Constitution? It clearly does.
12 S-21- Barrasso - No, The Press Has An Obligation, The Hunter Biden Laptop
📺 Barrasso — NBC MEET THE PRESS (?)
Barrasso (NBC MEET THE PRESS): "No president has ever thought they've gotten fair treatment from the press to be fair. But as you know, Senator, the First Amendment guarantees freedom of the press. Courts have barred the White House from banning access over their coverage.
13 S-22- Barrasso - He Was Banned From Twitter And Facebook, It Goes Both Ways
📺 Barrasso — NBC MEET THE PRESS (?)
Barrasso (NBC MEET THE PRESS): "I do want to ask about President Trump's decision to ban CNN, MSNOW, and Politico from the White House over their reporting, which he disagrees with. Do you agree with the president's ban, Senator? We all respect and value the freedom of the press. It's in the Constitution.
01 trump bans cnn, ms now and politico
01 01- Trump - Every President Takes An Oath, CNN Fake, MSDNC, Politico 8 Million
📺 Reporter — PBS NewsHour (MSM)
Reporter (PBS): "earlier today you posted that you intend to ban CNN, Politico and MS Now from the White House. Every president takes an oath to uphold the Constitution, which includes the First Amendment. I do too. How do you justify it?" Trump: "Much more so than you. Is this true? Because they're fake news.
02 02- Trump - Why Now, No Reason, Cumulative Stories, You Get Sick Of It
📺 Trump — PBS NewsHour (MSM)
Trump (PBS): "But our country has to have honest news. You know, you don't have a country unless you have, as I say, borders, good voting… Nobody's come into our country in the last 17 months illegally. But you need borders, and you need fair and free voting. And you know what you need? You need a free press.
03 03- NBC - Unprecedented Challenge To A Free Press, Not In My Office
📺 NBC NIGHTLY NEWS (?)
NBC (NBC NIGHTLY NEWS): "Tonight, in an unprecedented and escalating challenge to a free press, President Trump declared a ban on three news organizations… He also threatened other media outlets to follow. We pressed him in the Oval Office.
04 04- CBS - No Follow-Through, Acosta, Collins, AP And The Gulf Of America
📺 Anchor — CBS Evening News (MSM)
Anchor (CBS EVENING NEWS): "President Trump today claimed he's banning a trio of major media companies from the White House… But while he claimed on social media that the ban… was effective immediately, there was no immediate follow through, aside from a new round of the same old name calling… he may lose this one in court." Weijia…
05 05- CNN - A Country That Allows Negative Stories, King George Over Jefferson
📺 Anchor — CNN (MSM)
Anchor (CNN): "President Trump this afternoon in a social media post announced that he is going to ban CNN, MSNOW, and Politico from the White House… Moments ago, the president spoke about this ban from the Oval Office.
02 denied at the gate - saturday morning
01 01- ABC7 - CNN And MS NOW Turned Away, Passes Confiscated, The People's House
📺 ABC7 (?)
ABC7 (ABC7): "This just in. CNN says its reporter was turned away from the White House this morning… Just a short time ago, a CNN reporter and photographer were turned away and their press passes were confiscated.
02 02- ABC7 - Five Decades Of Courts, The AP Ruling, The WHCA Statement
📺 ABC7 (?)
ABC7 (ABC7): "For nearly five decades, courts have held that the First Amendment protects White House correspondents' freedom of speech and that their access to the complex can't be stripped based on the content of their reporting.
03 03- Akayla Gardner - The Reader Blinked Red, Above The Officer's Head
📺 Daniels — MSNBC (MSM)
Daniels (MS NOW): "For those who didn't hear earlier, can you walk through a little bit about what happened and most importantly, where things stand now with the White House?" Gardner (live outside the gate): "this morning around 7 a.m., our photographer first arrived here at the White House… and he was denied entry.
04 04- Akayla Gardner - No Press Secretary, They Want Loyal, CNN In The Pool Monday
📺 Akayla Gardner — MSNBC (MSM)
Akayla Gardner (MS NOW): "something I want to point out is the fact that right now the White House does not have a press secretary. That search is ongoing and at this point, that person would be expected to enforce this ban… And he named the Washington Post and the New York Times.
03 the first amendment - the lawyers
01 01- Trump - The Reporter Became A Joke, Depends On The Judge, DC Circuit
📺 Anchor — CNN (MSM)
Anchor (CNN): "I want to play this exchange because this was really important. A reporter asked the president about the chances of his ban succeeding when it is challenged in court… *In the first administration you tried a similar ban against CNN and it didn't survive a court challenge. What makes you think that this…* *Well, we'll see.
02 02- CNN - However Much You Kowtow The Bill Comes Due, Adams And The Sedition Act
📺 CNN (MSM)
CNN (CNN): "The president also suggested more to come. And he talked about the Washington Post and the New York Times… I think it's interesting, just as an object lesson, Jeff Bezos took over the Washington Post. Jeff Bezos made changes to the Washington Post.
03 03- MS NOW Legal - Strict Scrutiny, Viewpoint Discrimination, Such A Slam Dunk
📺 Hylton — MSNBC (MSM)
Hylton (MS NOW): "there's also this little thing called the Constitution. And you wrote yesterday that the short answer… about whether or not this is legal for the president to do is no. Walk me through that." James: "It's pretty easy analysis… the First Amendment doesn't bar every interaction between government and speech.
04 04- MS NOW Legal - Due Process, The Acosta Case - Arbitrary Impetuousness - What Chyron Did He See
📺 MS NOW Legal — MSNBC (MSM)
MS NOW Legal (MS NOW): "This is also, though… unconstitutional for a reason that is entirely separate from the First Amendment, and that is the notion of due process. And in the Jim Acosta case in the first Trump administration in 2018, it was actually on due process grounds that a Trump-appointed judge said you didn't give a reason, you…
05 05- Melissa Murray - Not Normal, Zenger 1735, A Free Press Is Why There Was A Revolution
📺 Melissa Murray — MSNBC (MSM)
Melissa Murray (MS NOW): "I think the American people need to know that this is not normal. The president does not have the authority under the First Amendment to deny access to the press pool.
06 06- Melissa Murray - No President Has Gone This Far, A Shot At The Smaller Outlets
📺 Melissa Murray — MSNBC (MSM)
Melissa Murray (MS NOW): "the president and the White House can perhaps restrict security credentials because you haven't been someplace or for legitimate reasons. They can't do it because you're reporting things that they don't want to see.
07 07- Melissa Murray - The ABC Settlement Concretized It, The AP Still Litigating
📺 Melissa Murray — MSNBC (MSM)
Melissa Murray (MS NOW): "This is not the first assault this president has made on the free press. If you think about those lawsuits that he has filed against ABC, against other news outlets, allegedly for defamation, many legal experts believe that those news organizations had really strong cases against the president.
08 08- CBS - Every Time He Explains It It's Worse For His Legal Case
📺 Jiang — CBS Evening News (MSM)
Jiang (CBS EVENING NEWS): "This ban will likely be challenged in court." Legal voice: "I think every time the president explains why he thinks this ban is necessary, it's actually worse for his legal case because he keeps talking about negative coverage and unfair coverage.
04 why now - and the 2009 cbs archive
01 01- Peter Alexander - Fake News Is Facts He Doesn't Like, Diesel At 6.48, Grenades
📺 Hylton — MSNBC (MSM)
Hylton (MS NOW): "you have been a White House reporter for more than a decade and you have pressed this president many, many times. So what do you think set him off last night?" Alexander: "the president made clear there wasn't any particular incident.
02 02- Peter Alexander - Cannot Handle The Truth, A Message To The Podcasters
📺 Hylton — MSNBC (MSM)
Hylton (MS NOW): "The Washington Post has this reporting… The president is starting to acknowledge his cratering poll numbers… why this ban then?" Alexander: "What was his name, Colonel Nathan Jessup? It was Jack Nicholson… in A Few Good Men who said, you can't handle the truth.
03 03- Peter Alexander - Ban Entering Not Reporting, Influencers Without Standards
📺 Peter Alexander — MSNBC (MSM)
Peter Alexander (MS NOW): "to be clear, he can ban reporters as he is trying to do. It will be blocked, I think, by the courts. He can try to ban reporters from entering, but he can't ban reporters from reporting… many of whom were surprised by this post as they have been by so many others.
04 04- Peter Alexander - A Reporter Told Blanche Great Job, We Are Advocates For Facts
📺 Peter Alexander — MSNBC (MSM)
Peter Alexander (MS NOW): Follow-on. "…one thing that struck me in the last several days was this past week when the attorney general Todd Blanche was doing the White House briefing from the Rose Garden, just steps from the Oval Office. First of all, I'd never seen anything like that before.
05 05- MS NOW - Ban On Free Press, Americans Know That Is Wrong, Not North Korea
📺 Hylton — MSNBC (MSM)
Hylton (MS NOW): "there's a new statement from the White House Correspondents Association… Today's action revoking access for journalists from CNN, Politico and MSNOW violates the First Amendment… I want to know how you see this story fitting into that bigger pattern." James: "I think this is an overstep for this White House, even…
06 06- CNN - Obama Tried To Exclude Fox, Will Fox Repeat That Same Affirmation
📺 CNN (MSM)
CNN (CNN): Former WH correspondent: "I remember when I was a White House correspondent back in the Stone Age, during the first Obama term, the Obama White House said that Fox was not a legitimate news organization.
07 07- CNN - Acknowledging He Is Losing, A 40-Minute Presser, Not Good Ball Control
📺 Anchor — CNN (MSM)
Anchor (CNN): "Is this not an acknowledgment that he is losing?" Republican strategist: "We found a way to get CNN to cover a press conference live for 40 minutes, which has not been possible in recent times. I do think, however… this is not good ball control for him.
08 08- CNN - No Press Secretary In Wartime, Why Serve A President Attacking The 1A
📺 CNN (MSM)
CNN (CNN): Former GOP spokesperson: "his administration has enabled him to get to this point. We saw the Justice Department… start subpoenaing reporters and reverse former DOJ precedent… They're trying to subpoena a reporter from their sources. They're trying to ban CNN.
09 09- CBS 2009 - Obama's War On Fox, Treasury Excludes Fox From The Pool, You've Crossed The Line
📺 CBS 2009 — NA-907 (?)
CBS 2009 (NA-907): setup = "the feud between President Obama and the Fox News Channel" · substance = Dunn: "the communications arm of the Republican Party… a talk radio format"; the Sunday-show snub; Treasury tries to exclude Fox from the pool · payoff = "It backed down after strong protests from the press.
10 10- CBS 2009 - Fox Not A Real News Organization, Tapper Objects, Crying To The Bank
📺 CBS 2009 — NA-907 (?)
CBS 2009 (NA-907): setup = "the White House is arguing that the Fox News Network is not a real news organization at all" · substance = Tapper at the podium; "why is the White House out to delegitimize Fox? Not because it has opinions…";